topspace (1K)
Home > Printer Reviews > HP > Pro Photo > HP Photosmart B8850 Photo Printer Review

HP Photosmart B8850 Photo Printer Review
by Richard Baguley

Navigation


  Canon Pro 9500 Mark II Comparison Summary  
x x • The Canon Pro 9500 Mark II is the more expensive printer by a significan margin
• The Canon has a much wider color gamut
The Canon has much deeper blacks, but color accuracy was not significantly higher
x   Samples Page 12 of 14 Conclusion  x

 

  HP B8850 Vs Canon Pro 9500 Mark II Specifications
  x x
  HP B8850   Canon Pro 9500 Mark II
Price $530 $849
Type Inkjet Inkjet
Color resolution
4800 x 1200 4800 x 2400
Black resolution
4800 x 1200 4800 x 2400
4 x 6 prints
Y Y
5 x 7 prints Y Y
8 x 10 prints Y Y
11 x 7 prints Y Y
13 x 19 prints Y Y
Banner prints Y N
DVD printing N N
Letter printing Y Y
Legal printing
Y Y
Tabloid printing
Y Y
Flat paper path Y Y
Fine art paper support
Y Y
Number of cartridges
Y 10
Ink Cartridge type HP38  Canon Type 9
Ink Cartridges Matte Black, Photo Black, Light Gray, Cyan, Magenta, Yellow, Light Cyan, Light Magenta  Photo Magenta, Photo Black, Matte Black, Photo Cyan, Grey, Magenta, Yellow, Cyan, Green, Red
Borderless printing
Y Y
Paper paths 1 2
Main paper tray capacity 200 120
Network N N
Media slots N N
PictBridge USB Y Y

Performance
The Canon Pro 9500 Mark II is the clear winner when it comes to the quality of the prints produced; it had a much wider color gamut and much deeper blacks. However, we did not find that either printer had much better color accuracy; in our tests, we found that both had problems with some colors, such as some of the blues and greens. Overall, the HP had slightly better overall accuracy, but the Canon isn't that far behind. And the Canon is the much better printer overall in terms of the range of colors and depth of blacks that it can produce.

    HP B8850 Vs Canon Pro 9500 Mark II: Color Accuracy Comparison
  HP B8850,
Default profile, HP Advanced Photo Paper
HP B8850,
Custom profile, HP Advanced Photo Paper
HP B8850,
Custom profile, Ilford Galerie Paper
Canon Pro 9500 Mark II, default profile
  Mean Color Error 7.1
4.8
4.5
5.3

 

HP B8850 Vs Canon Pro 9500 Mark II: Color Accuracy Comparison

HP B8850

Canon Pro 9500 Mark II flark

 

 

HP B8850 Vs Canon Pro 9500 Mark II:
dMax
Comparison

 

Inks & Media
Both printers use sets of 10 ink cartridges which include two blacks and a number of lighter inks; the HP uses a light magenta, a light cyan and a light grey, while the Canon uses a grey and a photo magenta and photo cyan. Both use two blacks; one for matte papers and one for glossy. The chemistry of the inks is different; the HP uses normal ink, while the Pro 9500 Mark II uses pigment inks.  What this also means is that the pigment inks of the Pro 9500 Mark II won't work well on most glossy photo papers; you need to use paper that can absorb the pigment ink.

Apart from that issue of paper type, both printers are pretty evenly matched when it comes to the sizes of papers that they can handle. Both can work with anything from a 4 x 6 print up to a monster 13 x 19 inch print. Neither can handle anything larger, though; they can't deal with larger banner sized prints.

In Use
The HP is the faster printer, but neither are going to win any land speed records. Printing a 13 x 19 print, the HP took 9 minutes and 13 seconds, while the Canon took a lengthy 11 minutes and 24 seconds.

 

HP B8850 Vs Canon Pro 9500 Mark II:
Photo Speed
Comparison

HP B8850

Canon Pro 9500 Mark II

 

HP B8850 Vs Canon Pro 9500 Mark II:
Document Speed
Comparison

HPB8850

x

2.06
Pages Per Minute

 

Canon Pro 9500 Mark II

x
 0.88
Pages Per Minute

 


[


<< Epson R1900 Comparison | Conclusion >>


Report an Error
Reviews   |   About PI   |   Advertising   |   Ethics   |   Sitemap
© Copyright 2010 PrinterInfo.com, all rights reserved. All trademarks and product names are property of their respective owners. PrinterInfo.com makes no guarantees regarding any of the advice offered on this web site or by its staff or users. All user comments and postings are not the responsibility of PrinterInfo.com.